Different starting points
The quickest way to choose between these two apps is to ask where your words are right now.
If they are in a file (a PDF from your course, a contract, a saved article, a page in a textbook), you want an app that can open that file and read it to you. NaturalReader’s listing describes exactly that: PDFs, Word and PowerPoint documents, cloud storage, web pages, e-books, and a camera scanner for printed pages. It adds study tools on top, such as summaries and quizzes.
If they are in your head or your notes (a script you are writing for a video, a story for your children, the narration for tomorrow’s presentation), you want an app built around the performance. Voice Labs gives you a text box, a library of 370+ voices with distinct personalities, and controls for how the line is delivered.
What Voice Labs does that NaturalReader does not list
- A voice changer. Record yourself, or import audio up to 5 minutes long, and re-voice it with any of the library voices while keeping your own timing and emphasis.
- Voices chosen for character. The library is organised around what a voice is for: a warm storyteller, a smooth audiobook reader, a character for animation.
- Delivery controls. Stability and similarity sliders change the performance, not just the speed.
What NaturalReader does that Voice Labs does not
- Opens documents. Voice Labs only takes text you type or paste, up to 5,000 characters at a time.
- Scans printed pages with the camera.
- More languages. Its listing says 90+, against 31 in Voice Labs.
- Study features such as summaries, quizzes and podcast-style recaps.
- Monthly and yearly billing, which costs less over a long period than weekly plans.
The honest summary
These apps are not really rivals. NaturalReader helps you take words in. Voice Labs helps you put words out. If your work involves both, there is nothing odd about having both on your phone.